Dialogue and listening…now, where have we heard this tripe before?

“to avoid a schism” - hasn’t anybody watched, listened or learned?  Yes, they might defer a de jure schism, but the de facto break is already real.

“The motion also contained a clause calling for a moratorium on any public comment from Kirk courts, committees and ministers on the issue, effectively gagging them.”

Telling Scotsmen to keep their mouths shut! Thanks for the laugh.

William Wallace would lift his kilt.

Always follow the money. We got our way, now let’s not complain or get mad, and keep sending in your money!    Statmann

Just like the family drunk, let’s not talk about it.

well, those who really care can talk about it in the privacy of their own homes.  Perhaps we should discuss the filioque clause.  Much more important….

Tim+ (#2), you’ve hit the nail on the head.  In fact, I agree with all of the first five commenters, but I think Tim’s point is especially important.  Heresy is implicitly schismatic, and the grossly unbiblical notion of moral relativism that underlies disastrous decisions like this CoS decision, or TEC’s momentous and catastrophic decision to go ahead with Gene Robinson’s consecration in 2003, is both heretical and inherently schismatic.

There is no evading the dilemma.  Biblical Christianity is inevitably polarizing and divisive in a fallen world.  So division in our modern western world is inevitable.  The only question is this: will our churches prefer to maintain unity with a secularized, increasingly anti-Christian society at the cost of proving unfaithful to Christ and the authentic gospel and splitting internally, or will our churches stay united and faithful to the gospel while accepting the cost of incurring the misunderstanding and hostility of the surrounding world?  Those really are the only choices.

David Handy+

Re #6
JW,

Perhaps we should discuss the filioque clause.  Much more important….

That and homosexual marriage do have one thing in common.  They are both heretical.

Christ is risen!
John

After creating a major fact on the ground, they tell everybody to shut up. So if a minister defies the gag order, he will be defrocked - but it’s OK for Mr Rennie to have (homo)sexual relations outside of Christian marriage?

They are giving the TEClub ideas. Enough of the listening process. Abandonment of communion for even discussing homosexuality! (See the Anglican Curmudgeon’s latest.)

Is the gag order for clergy only?

“Telling Scotsmen to keep their mouths shut! Thanks for the laugh.”
=====================================================================

I agree.  The Kirk doesn’t seem to know the temperament of its own people.
What the Kirk gave as an order is, in its actual effect, a ‘challenge.’