Are there Christian themes, of course there are, is it actually a good thing to espouse as Christian, that’s another question.  One of my biggest problems is that as a “Children’s novel” the ‘hero’ Harry is quite un-Christian in many ways which are often hyped as some of his better qualities.  Just to say a couple are that he is often selfish, and that he bucks legitimate authority for his own reasons.  Of course if all we really want is for kids to read, let them read, who cares what their model looks like.

Hmmm, #1, from your description of Harry, he sounds like a typical Christian, lol. But from having read the books a few times each, I can say that he has FAR more admirable Christian qualities than he does faults. Heroes aren’t perfect; what makes them heroes is that they do wrestle against their faults to do that which is noble and unselfish and to fight against evil.

Only the Savior was sinless and J.K. Rowling does not endeavor to portray Harry as a metaphoric savior of the world. As Dumbledore tells Harry often in the books and a few times in the movies, it’s our choices that define us. And Harry is quick to acknowledge his faults and unworthiness. They are not glorified.

Almost every time an Ivy League university is mentioned I find another reason not to worry about missing that educational experience.  There’s a course that would be a waste of time at a community college, and much less expensive.

Gosh #3, you mean that studying pop culture isn’t education?  I’m shocked! lol

Perhaps she has read John Granger, the hogwarts professor, in his publications or at his website: http://www.hogwartsprofessor.com/  ?
I might find and read her text to see if she cites him, as is most justly due.

LOOKING FOR GOD IN HARRY POTTER, 2004, was the first large publication nationally by a Christian publisher.  Mr. Granger’s work precedes that by some years.

It reassures me that the trivial and irrelevant is still alive and well in Ivy education. L