Gavin Dunbar: New Orleans and Savannah

Posted by Kendall Harmon

It was hardly a surprise but a cause for sorrow nonetheless: the House of Bishops, meeting in New Orleans, made a response to the requests of the Primates at Dar Es Salaam that offered little to repair the “tear in the fabric of the communion” caused by the consecration of Gene Robinson. They did pledge compliance in the election of bishops (no more Gene Robinsons) – but then demanded that Gene Robinson be invited to Lambeth Conference in 2008. Their convoluted pledge not to authorize same-sex blessings is surely designed to permit local option (as is already happening). They demanded that the Global South Primates stop their pastoral interventions, but they had nothing serious to offer the conservative dissenters the Primates are trying to care for: the Pastoral Council proposed by the Primates was refused in favour of window-dressing; and the destructive policy of aggressive litigation against conservative dissent was not even addressed, let alone restrained.

Some will adjudge the result the best that could be hoped for under the circumstances. Others will even eagerly claim to find it satisfactory. But who really believes that is true? These are grudging assurances in words that inspire no trust, weasel words with built-in wiggle-room, a tactical maneuver, not a change of heart. The House has not renounced the imagined right of the Episcopal Church to do as it pleases, unconstrained by the teaching of the Bible, the historic Faith, or the Communion’s “bonds of affection”. They have not healed the breach their arrogance opened up, and that means it will only get worse.

The breach has now come to Savannah, in the decision by the Vestry of Christ Church to secure its future in the Faith, in the Anglican Communion, by placing the parish under the pastoral care of John Guernsey, a Virginia priest recently made bishop of the Anglican Church of Uganda in North America. This decision, made in conscience, cannot have been easy to make, and it deserves respect even from those who disagree with it. St. John’s Vestry has made no such decision, but I can testify to our respect for theirs; and also our continuing fellowship with them in the historic faith, and in “the bonds of affection”.

In response Bishop Louttit has asserted the Episcopal Church’s claim to Christ Church’s real property, on the grounds that parishes are “integral and constituent parts of a diocese and of the larger church.” But the obligations of “constituent” membership in the “larger church” run both ways. The constitutional obligations of the Episcopal Church - to uphold the Bible’s teaching, the Church’s historic Faith and Order, and membership in the Communion – are the covenantal basis of its canonical claims to parochial real property. If it cannot fulfil the former, then the moral basis for the latter disappears.

--The Rev. Gavin Dunbar is rector, Saint John's, Savannah

Filed under: * Anglican - Episcopal- Anglican: CommentaryEpiscopal Church (TEC)TEC BishopsSept07 HoB MeetingTEC ConflictsTEC Conflicts: GeorgiaTEC Departing Parishes

5 Comments
Posted October 4, 2007 at 1:36 pm [Printer Friendly] [Print w/ comments]



1. robroy wrote:

Father Dunbar brings up the hypocrisy of the TEC that others have as well. In questions of canon law, the adhere firmly to the very question Dennis canon, but play fast and loose all other canon law.

October 4, 2:05 pm | [comment link]
2. jeff marx wrote:

“But the obligations of “constituent” membership in the “larger church” run both ways.”
There is nothing I can add to this. Dialogue and conversations and listening are empty words unless and until this principle is embraced. Mutual obligations and Christian charity.

October 4, 3:15 pm | [comment link]
3. Little Cabbage wrote:

robroy, you certainly nailed that one!  Great job!

October 4, 4:27 pm | [comment link]
4. chips wrote:

What is the over and under on what St John’s will decide?

October 4, 5:21 pm | [comment link]
5. Dee in Iowa wrote:

Chip - I truly think the natives of Savannah are restless tonight….

October 4, 8:49 pm | [comment link]
Registered members must log in to comment.




Next entry (above): Episcopalians in Quincy updated on possible split with main denomination over homosexuality

Previous entry (below): School Keeps Christmas, Halloween; Adds Ramadan

Return to blog homepage

Return to Mobile view (headlines)