It’s been 15 years since I’ve engaged in the insane national (U.S.) tradition of flocking to the malls for the [pre-]Xmas “holiday” season leading up to December 25. Clearly, from reading Pollard, the oxymoron of “secular holiday” is simply over the heads of both Jews and Christians, and probably Muslims as well.

Let us remember that now is the time of the Christmas Holy-Days. Today is the Third Day of Christmas. It will remain Christmas until the Twelfth Day.

A Happy Feast of the Nativity of Our Lord to you all!

Aye, the eye of the needle gets ever smaller….

Christmas is “religion-free” only if one makes the unfortunate choice to make it so.

The arrogance here is unusually hard to tolerate, perhaps because he is talking about something he knows, really,nothing about. There is a smugness, a condescension that, quite frankly, makes me want to give his head a good whack.

  But the rest of us know what he does not. So a Merry Christmas to you, a long, healthy, prosperous New Year, and keep Christmas right out to Epiphany. It is probably no accident that Jan. 6 is when the sun starts to rise earlier each morning.  Larry

Yes, let’s all try to keep Christmas to Epiphany.  I know I will.

Br. Michael, to quote a great spiritual leader,

There is no try.

There is only do.

....Yoda

I’ll be with you, Br. Michael. Yes, the US and GB has a secular holiday called Christmas (or, “The Happy Holidays”) and let others enjoy it. And they can even ignore homilies and greetings from prelates and priests. But that will not stop any of us from witnessing the Twelve Days that we celebrate the Incarnation of the Word into our Flesh, that wonderful mystery that has called and still calls us to full humanity.

#7, BfB, I don’t understand your last sentence “calls us to full humanity.”  Please explain.

I let Bob answer, but for me it makes perfect sense:

Jesus the Christ came not only to redeem us from sin, but to restore us to the pre-fall imago Deo (I hope I’m spelling that right)—the image of God—and thus to all God meant us to be as human beings, i.e., our full humanity and human-ness as God intended.

It’s important to take this sort of critique seriously. As Charley says, “the eye of the needle” is getting smaller. Thanks be to God.

As for “whacking in the head,”  of course that is quite unacceptable from any Christian standpoint. Rather, we will need to endure the pain in our own head that comes from such writings and state of culture. And we will need to show great good will and once-a-year herculean effort to evangelize those who show up in our parishes. Trying hard to keep their sound-bite attention span while they check their cell phones through no fault of their own. That is our lot, and it’s a heck of a lot better than the lions.