Roman Catholic Health Care Debate: Helen Alvaré responds to Commonweal and Timothy Jost

Posted by Kendall Harmon

With so much water already under the bridge, it seems a risky move to wade into the debate between Commonweal (and its apparent legal advisor, Professor Timothy Jost) and the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) at this stage of the debate over the contents of the health care reform law (the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act or PPACA). On the other hand, it might be the perfect time to step back and survey the prolific exchange. Commonweal’s editors just don’t seem to trust the USCCB’s legal or policy analyses of the PPACA insofar as freedom of conscience or abortion are concerned.

Conversely, Commonweal has extended every benefit of the doubt to the opinions of one professor, Timothy Jost, who not only has no record of cooperation with Catholic moral and policy interests along the consistent ethic of life, but seems to regard Catholic contributions to moral reasoning about law with animosity, comparing Catholic influence to the establishment of an Iranian theocracy. Furthermore, Jost seems to be a strident partisan across the board, a condition best (and hilariously) exemplified in his May 17 editorial for Politico, wherein Jost wrote how “unimaginable” it would be for American voters to want Republicans back in government when, under the Democrats, the “economy has come roaring back.”

Meanwhile, The USCCB’s uniquely nonpartisan voice—even in the midst of some of the nastiest inter-party exchanges in recent history—successfully held together advocacy against killing the unborn with advocacy for expanding health care insurance to all Americans. Yet Commonweal, it seems, would not be satisfied with anything less than a full-throated blessing of whatever the House majority decided to offer pro-life Americans while in the throes of desperate, last-minute negotiations.

Read it all (and follow the links if you haven't followed the debate).

Filed under: * Culture-WatchHealth & Medicine--The 2009 American Health Care Reform DebateReligion & Culture* Religion News & CommentaryOther ChurchesRoman Catholic* TheologyEthics / Moral Theology

3 Comments
Posted July 21, 2010 at 8:45 am

To comment on this article: Go to Article View

The URL for this article is http://www.kendallharmon.net/t19/index.php/t19/article/31178/



1. Paula Loughlin wrote:

Thank you for posting this.

July 21, 2:24 pm | [comment link]
2. Dan Crawford wrote:

The difficulty taken by the stance of the USCCB is that its statements have been taken to be extremely partisan and exploited as such by the political party which did nothing to seek compromises that dealt with health care reform. That some Catholic Bishops (among them the Archbishops of Denver and St. Louis) have made the furtherance of the Republican political and social agendas their primary political focus has further diminished the credibility of Church’s leaders.

July 21, 5:54 pm | [comment link]
3. TridentineVirginian wrote:

That some Catholic Bishops (among them the Archbishops of Denver and St. Louis) have made the furtherance of the Republican political and social agendas their primary political focus has further diminished the credibility of Church’s leaders.

I think you mean to say, “that some Catholic bishops (among them the Archbishops of Denver and St. Louis) have made the furtherance of orthodox Christian faith and witness their primary political focus has further diminished the credibility of the Church in the eyes of the proponents of the Culture of Death.” That’s an accurate statement of the facts, vis a vis Abp. Chaput and Abp. Burke (whom I think you meant, though he is no longer in St. Louis) and the health care debate.

July 21, 6:12 pm | [comment link]


© 2014 Kendall S. Harmon. All rights reserved.

For original material from Titusonenine (such as articles and commentary by Dr. Harmon) permission to copy and distribute free of charge is granted, provided this notice, the logo, and the web site address are visible on all copies. For permission for use in for-profit publications, please email KSHarmon[at]mindspring[dot]com


<< Back to main page

<< Return to Mobile view (headlines)